416-901-9984

Gift Or Resulting Trust? Ontario Court Of Appeal Orders New Trial Over $30 Million Given To A Caregiver

When someone gives away money during their lifetime, the question after their death is often simple to state and hard to answer: was it a gift, or is the recipient holding it for the estate? In Ontario, the law starts from a firm answer. Equity presumes a bargain, not a gift. The person who received the money has to prove otherwise.

In Waters Estate v. Henry, 2026 ONCA 704, the Court of Appeal for Ontario applied that rule to one of the largest lifetime-transfer disputes the province has seen. Over ten years, a wealthy philanthropist transferred more than $30 million to the woman hired to care for his housebound wife. 

The trial judge found most of it was a gift. The Court of Appeal set that finding aside and ordered a new trial, holding that the trial judge had effectively reversed the burden of proof. 

What Happened In Waters Estate v. Henry

Dr. William Waters was a businessman, business professor, and philanthropist. Gillian Henry was hired to care for his wife, Phyllis. Between 2009 and 2019, William transferred money to Ms. Henry on at least 393 occasions, by cheque, direct deposit, and payments to a credit card. The total exceeded $30 million.

Roughly $19 million went into real estate. Ms. Henry bought nearly two dozen properties, held through companies she incorporated, and spent millions on renovations. The rest funded cars, trips, jewellery, registered savings for her family, and the discharge of a relative’s mortgage. There was no forensic accounting of where the money went. William and Ms. Henry shared a long, private relationship that his family, friends, and advisors knew nothing about.

After William died, his estate trustees discovered the scale of the transfers and sued, arguing that most of the money was invested, not given, and that the properties were held in trust for the estate.

At trial, the Superior Court largely sided with Ms. Henry. It found that, except for an 80 percent interest in a horse-boarding business called King of Hearts, she had rebutted the presumption of resulting trust. It also ordered her to repay $2.85 million that had come from Phyllis’s own funds, plus about $970,000 in outstanding loans.

The Presumption Of Resulting Trust

The governing rule comes from the Supreme Court of Canada in Pecore v. Pecore, 2007 SCC 17. When property is transferred for no consideration, the law presumes the recipient holds it on a resulting trust for the person who gave it. To keep it, the recipient must prove on a balance of probabilities that the transferor actually intended a gift at the time of the transfer.

That flips the usual civil burden. Ordinarily the plaintiff must prove its case. In a gratuitous-transfer dispute, the estate challenging the transfer does not have to prove the deceased meant to keep an interest. The recipient has to prove the deceased meant to give one up. Where the evidence is thin either way, the presumption often decides the case. (For a broader overview of how these trusts arise, see our page on constructive and resulting trusts.)

The Court of Appeal agreed the trial judge had stated this law correctly. The problem was how he applied it. The court identified three related errors.

Error One: "He Never Documented It" Is Not Proof Of A Gift

The trial judge put significant weight on the fact that William, when he wanted repayment, usually papered the loan through counsel. Where there was no paperwork, the trial judge treated the silence as supporting a gift.

The Court of Appeal held that this effectively reversed the onus. It was not for the estate to show William kept an interest in the money and properties. It was for Ms. Henry to show he gave that interest up. The absence of loan documents may sometimes support a gift, but not automatically, and not here: Ms. Henry herself acknowledged certain undocumented debts to William.

The court also faulted the trial judge for reasoning that because some transfers were gifts, nearly all of them were. Nearly 400 transfers over a decade, in different amounts and for different purposes, could not fairly be explained by a single, uniform intention. A trial judge need not analyze every transaction separately, but the evidence here called for some particularization, at a minimum distinguishing money used to buy property from money spent on personal items and debts.

Error Two: The Deceased's Own Notes Should Not Have Been Excluded

William was a note-taker. After his death, the estate found handwritten notes listing properties Ms. Henry had bought, with dollar figures beside them. The trial judge excluded almost all of them as unreliable hearsay because some of the details in them were inaccurate or unsupported by other evidence.

The Court of Appeal held that the trial judge analyzed the wrong thing. The estate was not relying on the notes for the truth of each figure. It was relying on them for a broader inference: a man who had truly given property away would have little reason to keep tracking it. On that use, the reliability concern largely fell away. William wrote the notes to himself, and it is illogical to suggest he was deceiving himself, or mistaken, about his own interest.

The court also noted the inconsistency in admitting one note (the one supporting the King of Hearts finding) while excluding the others, even though that note also contained inaccuracies. Admissibility at the new trial will be for the new trial judge, but the Court of Appeal’s guidance, including its observation that the notes may be usable for a non-hearsay purpose, will shape that fight.

Error Three: A Close Relationship Is Context, Not Corroboration

Claims against an estate carry a statutory safeguard. Under section 13 of Ontario’s Evidence Act, a party suing or defending against an estate cannot win on their own evidence about matters before the deceased’s death unless it is corroborated by some other material evidence. The deceased cannot answer back, so the law requires independent support. Drawing on Brisco Estate v. Canadian Premier Life Insurance Company, 2012 ONCA 854, the Court of Appeal described section 13 as an exception to the general rule that one witness can meet the burden of proof. The corroborating evidence must be independent.

The trial judge leaned heavily on his finding that William and Ms. Henry were in an intimate relationship, treating it as the explanation for the “seemingly inexplicable” transfers. The Court of Appeal accepted that a relationship can be relevant: people close to one another are more likely to give gifts. But it held the relationship was given undue prominence. Most of the evidence about it came from Ms. Henry herself, and her evidence could not corroborate itself. William had also transferred $800,000 in her first month of employment, before any long-standing relationship could have formed.

Credibility mattered too. The trial judge had rejected Ms. Henry’s evidence on other important issues and found she had misrepresented her finances in her own family-law proceedings. A trier of fact may accept some of a witness’s evidence and reject the rest, but the question remained whether the evidence was enough to rebut the presumption and was independently corroborated. In the court’s view, the relationship was “more context than corroboration.”

Limitation Periods Reopened 

The trial judge had also found that some of the estate’s claims were time-barred: non-property claims under the two-year period in the Limitations Act, 2002, and claims to four early properties under the ten-year period in the Real Property Limitations Act.

The Court of Appeal set those rulings aside. When a resulting trust is alleged, the limitation clock does not necessarily start on the date of transfer. Discoverability turns on what the transferor intended, how the recipient treated the money, what the transferor knew about that, and what a reasonably diligent person would have known. Those questions are bound up with the gift issue itself, so they will be decided afresh at the new trial.

Why This Case Matters

Waters Estate v. Henry is a high-dollar case, but its lessons apply to ordinary estate disputes over money moved before death, whether to a caregiver, a new partner, a friend, or an adult child.

  • For estate trustees: The burden sits with the recipient. If you find large or unexplained transfers in the deceased’s records, the absence of loan paperwork does not end the inquiry. Preserve the deceased’s notes, ledgers, and correspondence, even if they look incomplete. Estate trustees have a duty to recover estate assets and will ultimately have to account for them on a passing of accounts.
  • For recipients: A close relationship with the deceased helps explain why a gift was plausible, but it will not carry the case on its own. You will need independent evidence of the deceased’s intention at the time of each transfer, or category of transfers, to satisfy section 13 of the Evidence Act.
  • For anyone making significant lifetime gifts: If you intend a gift, say so in writing at the time. Clear contemporaneous documentation is the single most effective way to prevent your estate and your intended recipient from litigating your intentions after you are gone.
  • On timing: Do not assume a limitation period has expired simply because the transfers are old. Discoverability in resulting trust claims is fact-specific and may run later than the transfer date.

The presumption of resulting trust has also generated litigation in other contexts. Our earlier article explains why the presumption does not apply to RRIF and TFSA beneficiary designations.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who Has To Prove That A Transfer Was A Gift In Ontario?

Broadly speaking, the person who received it. When money or property is transferred without consideration, Ontario law presumes a resulting trust in favour of the transferor or their estate. The recipient must prove, on a balance of probabilities, that the transferor intended a gift at the time of the transfer.

What Is The Corroboration Rule In Estate Litigation?

 Section 13 of the Evidence Act provides that an opposite or interested party in an action by or against an estate cannot obtain judgment on their own evidence about matters before the deceased’s death unless that evidence is corroborated by other material evidence. Corroboration can be direct or circumstantial and can come from several pieces of evidence considered together.

How Long Does An Estate Have To Sue To Recover Lifetime Transfers?

It depends on the claim. Claims to money are generally subject to the two-year basic limitation period, and claims to an interest in land to a ten-year period, but both run from when the claim was discovered or ought to have been. In resulting trust cases, the Court of Appeal has confirmed that discoverability is fact-specific and does not necessarily begin on the date of the transfer. Get advice early.

Pinto Shekib LLP, Your Toronto Estate Litigation Lawyers

Whether you are an estate trustee trying to recover assets transferred before death, or a recipient whose gift is being challenged, the outcome will turn on the evidence of intention and how early it is gathered and preserved. Pinto Shekib LLP acts for estate trustees, beneficiaries, and recipients across Ontario in estates, wills and trusts litigation, including resulting trust and gift disputes.

Call 416-901-9984, email info@pintoshekib.ca, or book a consultation.